Distribute Direct and Indirect Costs Across Analysis Centers

2024/04/17
Jérôme Keller
Distribute Direct and Indirect Costs Across Analysis Centers

In management accounting, the distinction between primary centers and auxiliary centers is fundamental for precise cost distribution and effective resource management.

Primary Centers, also known as Main Centers, are directly involved in the production of goods or services intended for sale. They are the main engine of operational activity and have a direct impact on the organization's profitability. In contrast, Auxiliary Centers, although not directly involved in production, play a crucial role by providing essential support services for the operation of Primary Centers.

In this article, we will explore these two types of centers, highlighting their roles, typical examples, and cost allocation methods that allow for fair and precise distribution of indirect costs within the organization.

If you want to know how to identify your Primary and Auxiliary Centers, we recommend consulting: Identifying your Primary and Auxiliary Centers from the Value Chain of your organization.

Definition of Auxiliary and Primary Centers

In management accounting, it is crucial to distinguish between primary centers, which are directly involved in the production of goods or services, and auxiliary centers, which provide essential support services.

Primary Centers

Primary Centers, also known as Main Centers, are often departments or units directly involved in the production of goods or services intended for sale. They are at the heart of the organization's operational activity and directly generate revenue. The costs and performance of primary centers are often closely monitored as they have a direct impact on the organization's profitability.

Examples of Primary Centers: Production, Sales, Marketing, or Research and Development

Auxiliary Centers

Auxiliary Centers are also often departments or units within an organization that provide services or resources to other departments (primary centers and other auxiliary centers). Their role is to support the operations of primary centers by ensuring essential functions such as maintenance, cleaning, or accounting. Although they are not directly involved in the production of goods or services intended for sale, their contribution is indispensable for the smooth running of the organization.

Examples of Auxiliary Centers: Maintenance, Cleaning, IT Services, or Human Resources

By understanding the distinction between these two types of centers, we will better grasp the differences between allocation methods for distributing indirect costs within an organization.

Cost Allocation Methods

Cost allocation methods for Primary and Auxiliary Centers channel expenses precisely and fairly within an organization. There are mainly three approaches: the direct method, the step-down method, and the reciprocal method. Each has its advantages and limitations in terms of complexity and precision in cost distribution.

Direct Method

The direct method consists of allocating the costs of Auxiliary Centers directly to Primary Centers without passing through other auxiliary centers. This method is simple to implement and understand. However, it does not take into account the services provided by Auxiliary Centers to each other.

Example

alt_Esay Orga_Direct Method of Cost Allocations to Primary and Auxiliary Analysis Centers.svg

If the maintenance department (auxiliary center) and the cleaning department (auxiliary center) provide services to production and marketing (primary centers), the costs of maintenance and cleaning would be directly attributed to production and marketing without considering the services that maintenance can offer to cleaning and vice versa.

Step-Down Method

The step-down method (or sequential distribution method) allocates the costs of Auxiliary Centers following a specific sequence. In this method, the costs of Auxiliary Centers are first allocated among themselves, and then the remaining costs are distributed to Primary Centers.

Example

alt_Esay Orga_Step-Down Method of Cost Allocations to Primary and Auxiliary Analysis Centers.svg

Suppose the cleaning department provides services to both the maintenance department and Primary Centers. First, the cleaning cost is distributed among maintenance and Primary Centers. Then, the maintenance costs, including those received from cleaning, are allocated to Primary Centers.

Reciprocal Method

The reciprocal method is the most precise because it takes into account the services provided among all Auxiliary Centers. It uses simultaneous equations to allocate the costs of Auxiliary Centers reciprocally before distributing them to Primary Centers.

Example

alt_Esay Orga_Reciprocal Method of Cost Allocations to Primary and Auxiliary Analysis Centers.svg

If the maintenance department and the cleaning department provide mutual services, the costs are first balanced among them using simultaneous equations. Once the costs between the Auxiliary Centers are balanced, the total costs are then distributed among the Primary Centers.

Cost Allocation from Primary Centers to Products and Services

Once indirect costs are allocated to Primary Centers, it is essential to distribute these costs among the various products and services they produce. This step gives us the Full Production Cost for each product or service, taking into account not only direct costs (such as raw materials and direct labor) but also indirect costs.

To allocate the costs of Primary Centers to products and services, it is crucial to identify the appropriate cost drivers, also called allocation bases or cost factors. These drivers reflect the relevant consumption of resources by each product or service.

Here are some commonly used drivers:

  • Indirect Labor Hours: to distribute indirect personnel costs among products according to the time spent by indirect employees on each product.
  • Machine Hours: to allocate machine costs based on the time each product uses the machines.
  • Occupied Space: to distribute building costs (rent, energy, maintenance) based on the space used by each production activity.
  • Quantity of Raw Materials Used: to allocate costs based on the quantity of raw materials consumed by each product.
  • Number of Orders or Deliveries: to distribute administrative and logistics costs based on the number of orders processed or deliveries made for each product.
alt_Easy Orga_Primary and Auxiliary Centers of an Automobile Manufacturer.webp

Cost Allocation from Products and Services to End Customers

After imputing costs to products and services, it is crucial to allocate them to end customers, who are not internal clients, but those who actually purchase the products or services. This ultimate allocation sets a Full Cost for each customer based on the products and services rendered, which is essential for pricing, profitability analysis, and strategic decision-making.

Example :
If a product is sold to different customers, the costs associated with its production (direct and indirect) are imputed to reflect the actual use of resources by each customer. This includes production, distribution, and any other costs associated with serving the customer.